Case Studies

Search Case Studies

All Areas of Concern

Search Case Studies

All Areas of Concern

Soliciting loans from a supplier

CS186
Trades / Industries:

A herbal tea manufacturing company sourced its raw materials from various Mainland suppliers. Mr Fong, a senior merchandiser of the company, was responsible for purchasing herbal materials and inventory control.

 

Recently, Mr Fong who had experienced financial difficulties was in desperate need of money.  He sent several text messages to a Mainland herbal supplier to solicit a loan of RMB60,000. Mr Fong suggested to the supplier that more purchase orders would be placed if the supplier deposited the money into his wife’s bank account in Hong Kong. The supplier made no response to the request. Shortly after, Mr Fong sent another text message to the supplier asking for another loan of RMB30,000 and threatened to cut the purchase orders if it was not granted. The supplier did not agree to his request, as it amounted to solicitation of bribes. The supplier then reported the matter to the management of the herbal tea manufacturer. In view of the severity of the matter and having no tolerance for solicitation of bribes by its staff, the management of the herbal tea manufacturer immediately reported the case to the ICAC.

Case Analysis

Soliciting bribes from overseas companies is also subject to prosecution

 

Though the supplier, from which Mr Fong solicited bribes, was outside Hong Kong, Mr Fong might still commit an offence of soliciting an advantage under Section 9 of the Prevention of Bribery Ordinance (POBO) as he sent text messages requesting for loans to be deposited into his wife’s bank account in Hong Kong in return for placing more orders.

 

Businesspersons should be aware that the POBO can apply when part of the corrupt act, e.g. promising, agreeing, soliciting or accepting advantages without permission, takes place in Hong Kong.

 

Accepting bribes, whether directly or indirectly, is against the law

 

Loan is considered an advantage under the POBO. Accepting bribes regardless of whether the advantage is directly given to the acceptor or indirectly delivered to a third party is still against the law. In the case study, if the Mainland herbal supplier agreed to deposit the loans into Mr Fong’s wife’s bank account in Hong Kong, as long as it was proven that the receiving account was controlled by Mr Fong or that he was the ultimate beneficiary, Mr Fong would be considered as having accepted the advantage.

Back To Top